| East | South | ||||||
| 1 | Team Matty J | Duke | 1 | Team Maher Sr. | Auburn | ||
| 2 | Team Sheehy | Alabama | 2 | Team Brettski | Michigan State | ||
| 3 | Team Ardito | Wisconsin | 3 | Monti's Marauders | Iowa State | ||
| 4 | Big D Hammer | Arizona | 4 | Team K-Shaun | Texas A&M | ||
| 5 | Team Belakonis | Oregon | 5 | Team Madden | Michigan | ||
| 6 | Team Sullivan | BYU | 6 | Team Breslin | Ole Miss | ||
| 7 | Team Dougie | St. Mary's | 7 | Clan McDaries | Marquette | ||
| 8 | Team Sancomb | Mississippi State | 8 | Team Finley | Louisville | ||
| 9 | Team Weireman (2) | Baylor | 9 | Team Quigley | Creighton | ||
| 10 | Team Cheeta (2) | Vanderbilt | 10 | Team Benny | New Mexico | ||
| 11 | Team Weireman (1) | VCU | 11a | Read the Line | San Diego State | ||
| 12 | Team Bernazzani | Liberty | 11b | Muscles | North Carolina | ||
| 13 | Team Stevie | Akron | 12 | Team Field | UCSD | ||
| 14 | Team Phuong/Nancy | Montana | 13 | Team Spaceman | Yale | ||
| 15 | Big Game James | Robert Morris | 14 | Team O'Brien | Lipscomb | ||
| 16a | Brady Train | American | 15 | Team Morrill | Bryant | ||
| 16b | Team Croke | Mount St. Mary's | 16a | Team Lachance | Alabama State | ||
| 16b | Team Gerkey | St. Francis | |||||
| MidWest | West | ||||||
| 1 | Team Houlihan | Houston | 1 | Rene Thompsom | Florida | ||
| 2 | Team Rocca | Tennessee | 2 | Team Taylor/Melancon | St. John's | ||
| 3 | Team Roelke | Kentucky | 3 | Team Jacques | Texas Tech | ||
| 4 | Team McGonagle | Purdue | 4 | Team Warner | Maryland | ||
| 5 | Teeple of Doom | Clemson | 5 | Team Freed | Memphis | ||
| 6 | Team Gardella | Illinois | 6 | Team Abdou | Missouri | ||
| 7 | Team Thach | UCLA | 7 | Team Commish | Kansas | ||
| 8 | Team Fiske | Gonzaga | 8 | Smokey & Bandit (Ford) | UConn | ||
| 9 | Dan Maher Jr. | Georgia | 9 | Team Baroni | Oklahoma | ||
| 10 | Team Pickles | Utah State | 10 | Team Gallagher | Arkansas | ||
| 11a | Team Nater | Texas | 11 | Team Cheeta (1) | Drake | ||
| 11b | Team Vernaglia | Xavier | 12 | Team Rouse | Colorado State | ||
| 12 | Team Squash Man | McNeese State | 13 | Team Mazzocchi | Grand Canyon | ||
| 13 | Team Piper | High Point | 14 | Team Gange | UNCW | ||
| 14 | Team Soup | Troy | 15 | Team Chids | Omaha | ||
| 15 | Team Dziadosz | Wofford | 16 | Team Cooney | Norfolk State | ||
| 16 | Noles | SIUE | |||||